This limited model of thinking does a great disservice to our clients. It sends a message that you are the way you are because of some combination of genetics and upbringing. It gives people a crutch, a reason to say, “I am who I am so don’t bother being more.” That is the opposite of empowering. If mental health professionals are to stay true to our mission of helping people lead fuller, happier lives, we need to give our clients a third option.
Nature versus Nurture versus New.
Yes, genetics play a part in who we are.
Yes, past experiences play a part in who we are.
However, if someone enters therapy thinking their fate is sealed because of their nature and their nurture, then counseling isn’t for them. For therapy and life to be successful, you have to believe you can control your situation and create the life you want.
You have to be willing to move beyond I was born that way...I’m just like my parents…It runs in my family…I will always be angry at them…You would be sad too if...
You have to believe something better is waiting for you. Something of your choosing. Something more than DNA and childhood.
You have to believe in the new.
Nature versus nurture versus new.
My money is on the fresh legs.
Do you need help rethinking a situation in your life? Email me at bradleyjabel@gmail.com
For information on anger management and individual counseling, contact me at
If you are a mental health professional and want creative consultation for your professional literature or Psychology Today profile, contact me at bradleyjabel@gmail.com